Media Nov Records is a year-old company with two shareholders. It fills YouTube with AI-generated loop videos that hardly anyone watches, and it sells a tool that files copyright takedowns automatically. In October that tool went after a real musician. Media Nov told YouTube it owned Samantha Shokin’s five-year-old recording of “Bre Petrunko,” a 19th-century Bulgarian folk song that nobody owns. YouTube’s automated system believed it. It took her video down, put a strike on her channel and threw out both of her appeals. Nobody at either company answered her.
A reporter got the video back. Media Nov ignored Shokin, but when 404 Media emailed it, it dropped the claim within minutes. Its stated reason shows what the claims are for: the video “has not generated revenue or received views.” The video had 125,000 views. YouTube put it back about a day later.
“Any human would agree with me that there’s something clearly wrong here that needs to be fixed, but I can’t get in touch with a human being.” Samantha Shokin, to 404 Media
The claim came from a content mill
Media Nov told 404 Media it runs 500 YouTube channels. 404 Media looked at four of them. Each held hundreds of videos of looping electronic beats over AI-generated pictures, posted again and again across channels, and many had fewer than 100 views. The company calls itself a music distributor, but its website mainly sells enforcement: automated takedown requests, YouTube Content ID management and “AI-powered content recognition.” “Our advanced AI identifies your music across platforms,” the site says. It doesn’t say who checks what the AI finds. Shokin said the website itself “seems to be entirely AI-generated.”
Its history is invented too. The site says Media Nov was founded in 1996. The Irish company register says it was incorporated on 10 October 2025. Its two shareholders gave addresses in Turkey, its registered address, a converted Dublin church turned office building, is shared with at least 2,882 other companies, and the Los Angeles phone number on its website was busy every time 404 Media called.

Alfred Steiner, an artist and copyright lawyer, told 404 Media what that looks like from outside: a small, understaffed company
“using a lot of different tools, probably a lot of AI, to identify tracks that are ostensibly owned by its clients and then automatically filing takedown requests.”
“They’re probably taking down far more than they have the right to take down,” he said. Asked which work in its catalog had matched Shokin’s recording, Media Nov did not answer.
YouTube’s system took its word
YouTube works through copyright claims with automated systems and tends to approve them automatically, 404 Media reported. The uploader can file a counter-notification. US law then gives the claimant 10 business days to show it has sued, or the video goes back up. But that clock starts only if YouTube accepts the counter-notification, and YouTube’s own help page says ones it finds incomplete “may be rejected.”
YouTube rejected both of Shokin’s. Its second reply read: “It’s unclear to us whether you have a valid reason for filing a counter notification, so we won’t be able to honor your request.” It told her to contact the copyright holder. For a song nobody owns, that meant Media Nov. Her emails went unanswered and its phone line did not seem to work. Loopmasters, a sample company that sells her recording in a sample pack and pays her royalties, wrote to Media Nov for her and was ignored too. Media Nov later said both emails had gone to spam.

Steiner said many platforms do the opposite. When an uploader says “I have the rights,” they put the video back, because “if they just put it back, they’re at no risk.” YouTube sided with the claimant twice.
| Removal request (used on Shokin) | Content ID claim | |
|---|---|---|
| The video | Taken down; the channel gets a strike | Usually stays up |
| The ad money | Stops, because the video is gone | Held during a dispute; goes to the claimant after 5 days if the uploader does nothing |
| The appeal | Counter-notification; the claimant must show legal action within 10 US business days or the video returns | Dispute; held money goes to “the appropriate party” once resolved |
How much of this YouTube sees
YouTube’s own figures show how much of the system runs without people. In 2025 it processed 2.5 billion Content ID claims, about 99% of all its copyright claims, and most of them are automated with no human involved, according to its transparency report as summarised by TorrentFreak. Removal requests filed through its public web form are a smaller stream, and a dirtier one. YouTube’s reviewers judged more than 6% of them in 2025 to be “a likely false assertion of copyright ownership,” an abuse rate more than 10 times that of its other copyright tools. Uploaders appealed 9.9% of web-form removals, a little over 267,000 counter-notifications.
That is the whole arrangement. A company with two shareholders can point software at YouTube and file claims at the scale of 500 channels, for almost nothing. YouTube’s software accepts the claim and rejects the appeal. The only cost lands on the musician whose video comes down.
It took a reporter
Media Nov’s withdrawal email also said it intends “to initiate appropriate legal proceedings regarding the underlying copyright dispute.” It still runs its 500 channels and still sells automated takedowns, and it has not said how many other videos it has claimed.
Filing a takedown for rights you don’t hold can make you liable for damages and legal costs under US copyright law, Steiner said. He also explained why that rarely stops anyone:
“If all of the people you end up offending are small parties and don’t have the resources to respond through the court system, and you are a fly-by-night entity that is hard to pin down and nobody knows who you are […] it can be difficult to get a remedy.”
Shokin got her video back because a journalist emailed a company that had ignored her. Nothing else in the process worked. The next musician Media Nov’s software flags will face the same two machines, and probably won’t have a reporter to call.
Further Reading
- How an AI Content Mill Put a Real Musician Through Copyright Hell, 404 Media’s investigation, with Media Nov’s emails and Steiner’s comments.
- Media Nov Records Limited, the Irish company register entry showing the October 2025 incorporation.
- YouTube Help: Submit a copyright counter notification, the 10-business-day rule and YouTube’s power to reject appeals.
- YouTube Processed 2.5 Billion Content ID Copyright Claims in 2025, TorrentFreak on YouTube’s 2025 copyright transparency figures, including the web-form abuse rate.
